Methods for studying pesticides migration: analysis, comparison, and recommendations for use in assessing the risk of pesticides impact on groundwater

В.Н. Колупаева

Abstract


Groundwater pollution with pesticides has affected every country on every continent. An important challenge for researchers and regulatorу bodies in all countries is to develop methods and tools for predicting the risks to groundwater that are associated with pesticide use. In this paper, the generally accepted methods for studying pesticides migration are reviewed and analyzed from the point of view of their applicability for assessing the risk of pesticides impact on groundwater. Using examples, it is shown that the available methods may be divided into two categories, direct and indirect ones. The indirect methods (mobility indices and field studies of pesticide migration) make it possible to compare the migration ability of a pesticide molecule and to determine the depth of penetration of the pesticide into the soil. The direct methods (modeling, lysimetric studies, and monitoring) provide for the determination of pesticide concentrations in groundwater or groundwater leachate, which makes such methods useful in assessing the risk of pesticide use. Thus, by comparing the measured pesticide concentrations in water with acceptable threshold values, it is possible to determine the risk level of a pesticide. Examples of calculating the mobility indices indicate that their estimates differ from each other. Disadvantages of migration field experiments are related to analytical problems and to the short duration of a study. Modeling the migration of pesticides is an effective tool that makes it possible to quickly determine pesticides concentration of in water runoff and to identify the pesticides that can pollute groundwater under specific soil and climatic conditions. Calculations show that for 40 pesticides out of 180 licensed for use in the Russian Federation, their predicted concentrations exceed 1 µg/l. The second method that allows to directly determine concentrations in leachate is lysimetric experiments. A long-term study of the migration of 4 pesticides showed that all toxicants migrate beyond the soil profile. A third useful tool is pesticides monitoring in groundwater. Further development and dissemination of this method for controlling pesticides in groundwater is an important task for the regulatory authorities and the scientific community of the Russian Federation in the near future.

Keywords


pesticides, groundwater, migration, sorption, pesticide fate model, lysimeter, monitoring


Как процитировать материал

References


Adielsson S, Törnquist M, Kreuger J. Pesticide monitoring at the catchment scale in Sweden. In: Del Re AAM, Capri E, Fragoulis G, Trevisan M, eds. Environmental Fate and Ecological Effects of Pesticides. Proc. XIII Symp. Pesticide Chem. Piacenza; 2007. P. 743-9.

Törnquist M, Kreuger J, Adielsson S. Occurrence of pesticides in Swedish water resources against a background of national risk-reduction programmes - results from 20 years of monitoring. In: Del Re AAM, Capri E, Fragoulis G, Trevisan M, ed.s. Environmental Fate and Ecological Effects of Pesticides. Proc. XIII Symp. Pesticide Chem. Piacenza; 2007. P. 770-7.

Steffens K, Jarvis N, Lewan E, Lindström B, Kreuger J, Kjellström E, Moeys J. Direct and indirect effects of climate change on herbicide leaching — A regional scale assessment in Sweden. Sci Total Environ. 2015;514:239-49.

Швыряев АА, Меньшиков ВВ. Оценка риска воздействия загрязнения атмосферы в исследуемом регионе. М.: Изд-во МГУ, 2004.

Горбатов ВС, Матвеев ЮМ, Кононова ТВ. Экологическая оценка пестицидов: источники и формы информации. АГРО XXI. 2008;1:7-9.

Потапов ИС, Горбатов ВС. Количественные закономерности сорбции имидаклоприда почвами. Агрохимический вестник. 2010;3:35-7.

Gustafson D. Hazards assessment; Groundwater ubiquity score: a simple method for assessing pesticide leachability. Environ Toxicol Chem. 1989;8:339-57.

Estes TL, Pai N, Winchell MF. Comparison of predicted pesticide concentrations in groundwater from SCI-GROW and PRZM-GW models with historical monitoring data. Pest Manag Sci. 2016;72:1187-201.

Belik A, Kokoreva A, Kolupaeva V. Migration of cyantraniliprole in fractured soils: calibration of pesticide leaching model by using experimental data. E3S Web of Conferences. 2020;169:01008.

Сметник АА, Спиридонов ЮЯ, Шеин ЕВ. Миграция пестицидов в почвах. М.; 2005.

Колупаева ВН. Формирование перечня пестицидов для их мониторинга в грунтовых водах. Проблемы экологического мониторинга и моделирования экосистем. 2018;29(3):93-106.

Синицына ОО, Хамидулина ХХ, Турбинский ВВ, Трухина ГМ, Башкетова НС, Гильденскиольд ОА, Амплеева ГП. Гигиеническое нормирование различных видов вод на современном этапе. Гигиена и санитария. 2022;101(10):1151-7.

Kolupaeva V, Gorbatov V, Nukhina I. Ecological zoning and assessment of the vulnerability of agricultural regions of the Russian Federation to groundwater pollution by pesticides. IOP Conf Ser: Earth Environ Sci. 2020;578:012037.

Умарова АБ. Преимущественные потоки влаги в почвах: закономерности формирования и значение в функционировании почв. Автореферат дисс…докт. биол.наук. М.ж 2008.

Kolupaeva VN, Kokoreva AА, Belik AA, Pletenev PA. Study of the behavior of the new insecticide cyantraniliprole in large lysimeters of the Moscow State University. Open Agriculture. 2019;4(1):599-607.

Kolupaeva V, Kokoreva A, Bondareva T. The study of metribuzin migration in lysimeters. E3S Web of Conferences. 2020;175.

Kolupaeva VN, Belik AA, Kokoreva AA, Astaikina AA. Risk assessment of pesticide leaching into groundwater based on the results of a lysimetric experiment. In: IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. International Conference on Key Concepts of Soil Physics: Development, Future Prospects and Current Applications. 2019; 012023.

Черногаева ГМ, Малеванов ЮА, Журавлева ЛР. Мониторинг загрязнения окружающей среды в Российской едерации: организация наблюдений, обобщение и распространение информации. Проблемы экологического мониторинга и моделирования экосистем. 2015;26(2):129-38.

Кузьмич ВН, Пономарева ЛС, Скурлатов ЮИ. Проблемы химической безопасности водных экосистем и новые подходы к оценке качества воды. Химическая и биологическая безопасность. 2015;(1-2):95-102.

Adielsson S, Törnquist M, Kreuger J. Pesticide monitoring at the catchment scale in Sweden. In: Del Re AAM, Capri E, Fragoulis G, Trevisan M, eds. Environmental Fate and Ecological Effects of Pesticides. Proc. XIII Symp. Pesticide Chem. Piacenza; 2007. P. 743-9.

Törnquist M, Kreuger J, Adielsson S. Occurrence of pesticides in Swedish water resources against a background of national risk-reduction programmes - results from 20 years of monitoring. In: Del Re AAM, Capri E, Fragoulis G, Trevisan M, eds. Environmental Fate and Ecological Effects of Pesticides. Proc. XIII Symp. Pesticide Chem. Piacenza; 2007. P. 770-7.

Steffens K, Jarvis N, Lewan E, Lindström B, Kreuger J, Kjellström E, Moeys J. Direct and indirect effects of climate change on herbicide leaching — A regional scale assessment in Sweden. Sci Total Environ. 2015;514:239-49.

Shvyriayev AA, Menshikov VV. Otsenka Riska Vozdeystviya Zagryazneniya Atmosfery v Issleduemom Regione. Moscow: MGU; 2004. (In Russ.)

Gorbatov VS, Matveev YUM, Kononova TV. [Ecological assessment of pesticides: Information sources and forms]. AGRO XXI. 2008;1:7-9. (In Russ.)

Potapov IS, Gorbatov VS. [Quantitative regularities in imidacloprid sorption by soils]. Agrohimicheskiy Vestnik. 2010;3:35-7. (In Russ.)

Gustafson D. Hazards assessment; Groundwater ubiquity score: a simple method for assessing pesticide leachability. Environ Toxicol Chem. 1989;8:339-57.

Estes TL, Pai N, Winchell MF. Comparison of predicted pesticide concentrations in groundwater from SCI-GROW and PRZM-GW models with historical monitoring data. Pest Manag Sci. 2016;72:1187-201.

Belik A, Kokoreva A, Kolupaeva V. Migration of cyantraniliprole in fractured soils: calibration of pesticide leaching model by using experimental data. E3S Web of Conferences. 2020;169:01008.

Smetnik AA, Spiridonov YuYa, Shein YeV. Migratsiya Pestitsidov v Pochvkah. Moscow; 2005. (In Russ.)

Kolupaeva VN. [Compilation of an inventory of pesticides for their monitoring in groundwaters]. Problemy Ekologicheskogo Monitoringa i Modelirovaniya Ekosistem. 2018;29(3):93-106. (In Russ.)

Sinitsyna OO, Khamidulina KhKh, Turbinskiy VV, Trukhina GM, Bashketova NS, Gildenskiold OA, Ampleyeva GP. [Current hygienic norm setting for different water types]. Gigiyena i Sanitariya. 2022;101(10):1151-7. (In Russ.)

Kolupaeva V, Gorbatov V, Nukhina I. Ecological zoning and assessment of the vulnerability of agricultural regions of the Russian Federation to groundwater pollution by pesticides. IOP Conf Ser: Earth Environ Sci. 2020;578:012037.

Umarova AB. Preimushchestvennye Potoki Vlagi v Pochvakh: Zakonomernosti Formirovaniya i Znachenie v Funktsionirovanii Pochv. PhD Theses. Moscow; 2008. (In Russ.)

Kolupaeva VN, Kokoreva AА, Belik AA, Pletenev PA. Study of the behavior of the new insecticide cyantraniliprole in large lysimeters of the Moscow State University. Open Agriculture. 2019;4(1):599-607.

Kolupaeva V, Kokoreva A, Bondareva T. The study of metribuzin migration in lysimeters. E3S Web of Conferences. 2020;175.

Kolupaeva VN, Belik AA, Kokoreva AA, Astaikina AA. Risk assessment of pesticide leaching into groundwater based on the results of a lysimetric experiment. In: IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. International Conference on Key Concepts of Soil Physics: Development, Future Prospects and Current Applications. 2019; 012023.

Chernogayeva GM, Malevanov YuA, Zhuravleva LP. [Monitoring of environmental pollution in the Russian Federation: the organization of surveillance and the synthesis and dissemination of information]. Problemy Ekologicheskogo Monitoringa i Modelirovaniya Ekosistem. 2015;26(2):129-38. (In Russ.)

Kuz’mich VN, Onomareva LS, Skurlatov YuI. [The problems of the chemical safety of aqueous ecosystems and the novel approaches to water quality assessment]. Khimicheskaya i Biologicheskaya Bezopasnost’. 2015;(1-2):95-102. (In Russ.)




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24855/biosfera.v14i3.692

© ФОНД НАУЧНЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙ "XXI ВЕК"